Sheriff defends patrol costs as commissioners debate township bills

Lucas County officials debated the price of policing their townships during a Tuesday budget review. The discussion centered on how much money Monclova and Springfield townships pay for extra patrol services and whether that revenue covers the true cost of those operations.

Sheriff Mike Navarre presented a budget projecting that the two townships will contribute nearly $3.3 million in 2027. He argued that the contracts, which go beyond the baseline service required by Ohio law, are structured to fully reimburse the county for the additional work.

Commissioners and staff disagree. They believe the $3.3 million estimate will not cover the expenses, forcing the county general fund to absorb the difference. Given the tight state of the county budget, officials see this potential shortfall as a major concern.

Commissioner Anita Lopez urged the sheriff to negotiate better terms. She stated that there is an opportunity to secure more revenue through the township contracts to strengthen the department's budget. Navarre countered that the new agreements will reimburse the county for personnel costs, including estimated 2027 wages.

The debate occurred despite orders for departmental cuts. Commissioners asked every department to reduce spending by 13%. Navarre eliminated 20 positions, yet his department's budget still rose 8.5%. The increase is driven primarily by wage hikes approved by the commissioners last year.

The county must submit its final budget by the end of the year. The dispute over township contracts remains a key factor in that calculation.